The triumph of individualism II

History of Economic Thought // Spring 2025

Prof. Santetti

marcio.santetti@emerson.edu

Comparing & contrasting

Comparing & contrasting


Sociology of religion

  • Q: What differentiates capitalism from other civilizations?

  • A: Pursuit of profits?

  • “The impulse to acquisition, pursuit of gain, of money, of the greatest possible amount of money, has in itself nothing to do with capitalism. This impulse exists and has existed among waiters, physicians, coachmen, artists […]” (p. xxxi)

Comparing & contrasting


Rationalism & Order

The key element: Organization of (formally) free labor.

Comparing & contrasting

Ethical/moral standards to regulations in society

  • How do they impact economic behavior?

  • ““On the one hand, it is evident that the whole body of regulations, by which modern societies set limits to the free play of economic self-interest, implies the acceptance, whether deliberate or unconscious, of moral standards, by reference to which certain kinds of economic conduct are pronounced illegitimate.” (p. 4)

The Medieval background

The Medieval background


Q: What is the essence of the transition from feudalism to capitalism?

A: Secularization of social theory.

“The political aspects of the transformation are familiar. The theological mould which shaped political theory from the Middle Ages to the seventeenth century is broken; politics becomes a science, ultimately a group of sciences, and theology at best one science among others. Reason takes the place of revelation, and the criterion of political institutions is expediency, not religious authority. Religion, ceasing to be the master-interest of mankind, dwindles into a department of life with boundaries which it is extravagant to overstep” (p. 6)

The Medieval background


Medieval vs. Capitalist societies:


  • Theoretical foundations

  • Social values

  • View of society

The Medieval background


“Between the conception of society as a community of unequal classes with varying functions, organized for a common end, and that which regards it as a mechanism adjusting itself through the play of economic motives to the supply of economic needs; between the idea that a man must not take advantage of his neighbor’s necessity, and the doctrine that “man’s self-love is God`s providence”; between the attitude which appeals to a religious standard to repress economic appetites, and that which regards expediency as the final criterion—there is a chasm which no theory of the permanence and ubiquity of economic interests can bridge, and which deserves at least to be explored.” (p. 13)

The sin of avarice

The sin of avarice


Q: What is avarice?


Two aspects:

  • Just price doctrine;

  • Usury.

The sin of avarice



The philosophical basis: Natural law.


Natural law involves two key aspects:

  • Ontological statement;

  • Moral imperative

The sin of avarice


“The philosophical basis of it [usury] is the conception of natural law. Every law framed by man bears the character of a law exactly to that extent to which it is derived from the law of nature. But if on any point it is in conflict with the law of nature, it at once ceases to be a law; it is a mere perversion of law […] The most fundamental difference between medieval and modern economic thought consists, indeed, in the fact that, whereas the latter normally refers to economic expediency, however it may be interpreted, for the justification of any particular action, policy, or system of organization, the former starts from the position that there is a moral authority to which considerations of economic expediency must be subordinated.” (p. 39)

The economic revolution

The economic revolution



What revolution?

The continental reformers

The continental reformers


Luther:

The life of the peasant


“God speaks to the soul, not through the mediation of the priesthood or of social institutions built up by man, but solus cum solo, as a voice in the heart and in the heart alone. Thus the bridges between the worlds of spirit and of sense are broken, and the soul is isolated from the society of men, that it may enter into communion with its Maker.” (pp. 96—97)

The continental reformers


Calvin:

Urban life

Three main doctrines:

  • Predestination;

  • The calling;

  • Worldly asceticism.

“Discipline. Calvin himself described as the nerves of religion,[63] and the common observation that he assigned to it the same primacy as Luther had given to faith is just.” (p. 115)

The Church of England

The Church of England


The land question


Enclosures movement



Consequences?

The Church of England


The growth of individualism


Now, natural law legitimizes human appetites:

“The law of nature had been invoked by medieval writers as amoral restraint upon economic self-interest. By the seventeenth century, a significant revolution had taken place. Nature had come to connote, not divine ordinance, but human appetites, and natural rights were invoked by the individualism of the age as a reason why self-interest should be given free play.” (pp. 179—180)

The Puritan movement

The Puritan movement


The new medicine for profit


Legislation against poor/unemployed population

Next time: Mercantilism & Physiocracy